Christian_pulisic_-_asn_top_-_usmnt_goal_celebration_vs._haiti_-_2026-11-17
USMNT analysis

Analysis: After a win over Haiti, USMNT heads into a transitional phase

ASN's Brian Sciaretta gives his thoughts on the USMNT win over Haiti and looks ahead to the bigger issues as to what is next
BY Brian Sciaretta Posted
November 18, 2026
5:00 AM

THE MAURICIO POCHETTINO ERA is now over. After the U.S. team’s 2-0 win over Haiti in Cincinnati in the second leg of the Nations League quarterfinal – which left the final aggregate score 8-0 – the program will now enter into a period of transition. The direction of that transition, however, is unclear.

There isn’t much to take away from the game itself. The 6-0 rout in the first leg essentially sealed the series and that the U.S. team would advance as the top seed.

In one surprising turn of events, Pochettino did not change his starting lineup from the first game. Top players like Christian Pulisic, Weston McKennie, Chris Richards, Tyler Adams, Antonee Robinson, Malik Tillman, and Alex Freeman all remained.

The clear highlight of the game came in the 25th minute when Pulisic hit a bicycle kick goal to open the scoring. It was superb hit to get on the end of a McKennie cross.



Then in the 43rd minute, it was Julian Hall with yet another goal. This time when he ran behind the defense, received a ball over the top from McKennie, and cooly finished from close range.



Hall, 18, now has five goals in his first six U.S. national team games. The teenager is coming off a great season with Red Bull New York where he scored 13 goals in MLS.

The second half was a lot more dialed back. One highlight came when Auston Trusty had a header cleared off the line by Martin Experience despite replay showing it crossing over the line.

Here are  a few other thoughts

 

Pulisic’s goal was a statement

 

Pulisic’s deserves all the praise he is getting for the bicycle. It gave this game a reason to be remembered.

 

It has not been the best year for Christian Pulisic for club or country but he has made a big turnaround the last two months with AC Milan. This was a way to remind fans after are mixed World Cup of why he is still so important to the team. Whoever manages this team will continue to be heavily reliant on him.

 

Pochettino’s mistake to play Berhalter

 

Pochettino won his final six games with the U.S. team and oversaw the team moving into the Nations League final rounds. But next spring when the U.S. team has to face Mexico in the semifinal, it will do so without Sebastian Berhalter who will be suspended.

There was no need to play Berhalter in this game and risk a suspension. He is too important of a player at this moment, and he is the best set piece taker in the player pool. There could very well come a time against Mexico when it would be beneficial to the team and the next manager to have Berhalter on the field.

 

Hall’s future

 

U.S. fans are excited over Julian Hall first six games with the U.S. team. The Red Bull teenager has some very important tools. He is mature beyond his years of finding ways to time runs so that he can get behind opposing backlines. He is also very effective with out he can quickly get a shot away.

He’s also not the first young American forward to come out of the gates roaring. Once Folarin Balogun returns to regular minutes and Ricardo Pepi is healthy to start consistently for PSV Eindhoven, Hall will be forced to compete with established Champions League players. He might just succeed, or he might not. But the Olympic team should not be out of the question as a place where he can lead a team in an important tournament.

 

Is Kochen the No. 1?

 

Pochettino did not elect to rotate goalkeepers and instead stuck with Diego Kochen for both games. This came after his clean sheet last window against Mexico.

Predicting how the next manager will see things is impossible, especially when it comes to very young and inexperienced players. It is a tall task for a new manager to immediately trust a 20-year-old goalkeeper whose only first team experience is with a relegation-battling team in Denmark.

But the fact that Pochettino stuck with Kochen will be something the next manager will surely take under consideration. But again, if the options for Kochen is to be a USMNT backup or an Olympic starter, the starting job should always be preferable.

He is clearly the best American goalkeeper in a few youth cycles.

 

Trusty as a potential starter

 

Playing with a heavy heart after the untimely passing of his father, Auston Trusty had a solid camp. With proper VAR review, he could have had goals in each of the legs this window.

With Ream’s retirement, there is an opening in central defense over who starts with Chris Richards. Trusty isn’t a clear choice to be that guy, but he is quietly performing well whenever given the chance.

Obviously, this was not the level of an opponent where anyone can evaluate a defender. Most American defenders in the broader playing pool could have helped the team to a clean sheet win against a seriously depleted Haitian team.

But Trusty will continue to be in the mix and continue to get serious opportunities regardless of whoever is coaching this team.

 

Cap-tying

 

This window marked only the second time in 2026 when players could be cap-tied to the U.S. program (the other being the World Cup).

In the first leg, dual nationals Julian Hall (Poland), Justin Ellis (Uruguay), Diego Kochen (Venezuela), Adri Mehmeti (Albania), and Mathis Albert (France) appeared for the U.S. team and are now tied.

In the second leg, Cavan Sullivan (Germany), Neil Pierre (Haiti), and Santiago Castaneda (Colombia) all appeared as substitutes in the second half and are now cap tied to the program.

 

The concept of “Dual National Panic” arguably receives way more attention than it deserves and the best thing about these players now being tied is that we don’t have to hear about it anymore.

 

December camp next

 

The U.S. team will return to action next month for a non-FIFA window camp and a friendly against Jamaica. This used to be know as January camp but because of MLS teams now starting preseason earlier, it has been moved back a month.

Steve Cherundolo will run this camp for the U.S. team and that makes sense given that he is now the Olympic coach. This camp is likely to be heavily oriented to players in the Olympic team pool. With MLS Cup taking place on December 18 and the friendly against Jamaica on December 13, the players available to Cherundolo won’t be known until that point of the playoffs. But we obviously won’t see any players involved in MLS Cup.

We will likely see Julian Hall and Adri Mehmeti as Red Bull New York missed the playoffs. That will allow Hall to continue to put up impressive numbers. We could also potentially see Diego Kochen as the Danish Superliga will be on its winter break at that point.

While a few top MLS performers who are past the Olympic age might take part (like Preston Judd, Milan Illoski, or Brian Schwake), the likelihood is that this camp is going to more closely be part of the Olympic team path than the full national team path.  

As for the next USMNT manager, it is way too early to put a timeline. If a coach like Pep Guardiola only wants to consider the job until after the summer, U.S. Soccer will have a decision to make.

If U.S. Soccer has a candidate in mind who is willing to listen now, things could happen quickly.

But the chances are high that U.S. Soccer was prepared for a Pochettino exit at any moment. It would not be surprising if there was always a list of candidates available that was updated periodically. The federation is likely a few steps ahead in this process than it would appear. The question then comes down to interviews and the level of the interests among the candidates.

Post a comment

AmericanSoccerNow.